Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages

223 Eanes Ln, Key West, FL 33040, Key West, United States

4-star hotel

Guest rating: 5.0 / 5

Overview

Andrews Inn & Garden Cottages is a laid-back, circa-1900 bed-and-breakfast in Key West, set just half a block from lively Duval Street. It’s positioned for walkable sightseeing while still offering an intimate, courtyard-style stay. The property is rated 5/5 from 176 public reviews and is listed as a 4-star hotel.

Rooms

Airy rooms feature tropical-inspired decor and include minifridges, flat-screen TVs, free Wi-Fi, and private bathrooms. Some rooms add fireplaces, sitting areas, and/or shared or private decks. Note that certain rooms are accessible via stairs only.

Food & Drink

A hot breakfast is served on-site, and the inn also hosts happy-hour drinks. Service is centered around the courtyard, creating a social but relaxed rhythm to the day for guests who want to be close to the action without relying on a car.

Outdoor Space & Extras

The courtyard includes an outdoor pool for cooling off between sightseeing and beach time. Parking is included, and guests have access to rental bikes plus loaner beach gear and towels. Minimum-stay rules may apply.

Location

The inn is a short walk from major Old Town sights, including The Hemingway Home and Museum (about 50 m) and the Key West Lighthouse (about 103 m). Other nearby highlights include the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory (about 527 m), the Southernmost Point (about 588 m), and Mallory Square and its Sunset Celebration (about 1.2 km). Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park Beach is roughly 1.18 km away, and favorites like Sloppy Joe’s Bar and the Mel Fisher Maritime Museum are also within about 1 km.

Best for

This property best fits couples and adult travelers who want an intimate B&B close to Key West’s main corridor—Duval Street is only about half a block away, and many Old Town sights are within easy walking distance. It also suits travelers who value included parking and on-site touches like hot breakfast, happy-hour drinks, a courtyard pool, and bike rentals for getting around without driving.

Travel tips

Plan to explore on foot or by bike: the Hemingway Home & Museum and Key West Lighthouse are just steps away, and Mallory Square is about a 15-minute walk for the Sunset Celebration. If you’re sensitive to stairs, ask about room access in advance, as some rooms are stair-only. Consider confirming length-of-stay requirements before booking since minimum-stay rules may apply.

What guests say

Reviews consistently emphasize the standout location, with guests noting how easy it is to walk to Duval Street and nearby Old Town attractions. Service is a major positive theme, with staff described as friendly and attentive, contributing to a quiet, intimate feel despite the central setting. Value-added inclusions—especially free parking, breakfast, and the happy-hour drinks—are repeatedly highlighted. No recurring negatives are mentioned in the provided excerpts, though travelers should be aware that some rooms require stairs based on property information.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure