Best Western Paint Pony Lodge
581 W Deuce of Clubs, Show Low, AZ 85901, Show Low, United States
2-star hotel
Guest rating: 4.4 / 5
Overview
Best Western Paint Pony Lodge is a 2-star hotel in Show Low, Arizona, set back from West Deuce of Clubs on a slight rise that helps buffer it from road noise. It holds a strong 4.4 rating from 538 reviews, reflecting a consistently positive guest experience for a budget-friendly, relaxed property. The lodge is positioned as a convenient base for exploring the White Mountains region's lakes, trails, and parks.
Rooms
Standard rooms are described as unassuming but functional, each equipped with a desk, free Wi-Fi, a flat-screen TV, minifridge, microwave, and coffeemaker. Upgraded rooms and suites go further with whirlpool tubs and/or fireplaces, appealing to guests wanting a bit more comfort or a romantic touch. Guests staying in suites have specifically noted enjoying the fireplace feature.
Amenities & Services
The hotel provides complimentary hot breakfast and afternoon cookies, along with free parking, making it easy on the budget for road-trippers and families alike. Guests also receive complimentary passes to a local fitness center, since the property itself does not appear to have an on-site gym. A lobby lounge with a computer and fireplace offers a comfortable common space, and on-site laundry facilities add practical convenience for longer stays.
Location & Surroundings
The lodge sits about 3 miles from both Show Low Regional Airport and Fool Hollow Lake Recreation Area, making it a practical option for fly-in visitors and outdoor enthusiasts. Show Low City Park is less than a kilometer away, and the Show Low Historical Society Museum is just over a kilometer from the property. Farther afield, guests can reach Show Low Lake, Rainbow Lake, the Mogollon Rim Trail, White Mountain Family Fun Park, and the broader White Mountains Trail System, all within roughly a 15-kilometer radius.
Best for
This lodge suits budget-conscious travelers and outdoor enthusiasts visiting the White Mountains region, given its proximity to Fool Hollow Lake, Show Low Lake, and multiple hiking trails. It's also a good fit for road-trippers and short-stay visitors who value complimentary breakfast, free parking, and a quiet setting just off a main road. Guests seeking a relaxed, no-frills stay with occasional upgraded comforts like fireplaces or whirlpool tubs will find suite options appealing.
Travel tips
Because the hotel is only about 3 miles from Show Low Regional Airport, it's a convenient overnight option for those flying in or out of the area. Take advantage of the free fitness center passes since the property itself doesn't have its own on-site gym. If you plan to visit Fool Hollow Lake Recreation Area or Show Low City Park, both are within a few minutes' drive or a short walk, so timing a morning visit before the day heats up is worthwhile.
What guests say
Guests consistently praise the staff and customer service, along with clean rooms and comfortable beds. Several reviewers highlight the suites' fireplaces and overall room quality as standout features, and food-related comments point to appreciation for the complimentary breakfast offerings. Multiple guests also note that the hotel is surprisingly quiet despite sitting on a main road, attributing this to its slightly elevated position, and they mention the lobby and covered outdoor sitting area as pleasant, comfortable spaces. No recurring negative themes are evident in the available excerpts.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure