Casa Lemon
Guest rating: 4.9 / 5
Overview
Casa Lemon is a charming 1-bedroom, 1-bathroom cottage set in Sarasota's historic Amish village of Pinecraft, Florida. Known locally as the Lemon Cottage, it sits above the main house and is currently under new ownership, with thoughtful upgrades underway. Its quiet, residential setting and private entry make it a low-key retreat for travelers who prefer a home-like base over a traditional hotel.
Rooms & Layout
The cottage offers a queen bed plus a futon for an extra guest, making it suitable for solo travelers or a couple with an occasional third person. A private entry keeps the unit separate from the main house, and guests have noted the slanted roofline typical of cottage architecture, which taller guests should keep in mind.
Amenities
In-unit conveniences include a kitchenette, air conditioning, heating, cable TV with streaming app access, and smoke-free rooms. Outdoor extras include a yard with a grill and shared laundry facilities on-site, while free on-site parking adds convenience for guests arriving by car.
Location & Surroundings
Casa Lemon is within walking distance of Pinecraft's Amish restaurants, bakeries, coffee shops, and markets, as well as neighborhood parks. Two bus stops (Bahia Vista St @ Hines Ave and Beneva Rd @ Bahia Vista St) sit just over 100 and 200 meters away, and it's a short drive to Sarasota's beaches and downtown waterfront restaurants. Sarasota Bradenton International Airport is about 9.8 km away, offering a reasonably convenient regional air link.
Best for
Casa Lemon is best suited to solo travelers, couples, and snowbirds seeking a quiet, well-located home base in Sarasota rather than a full-service hotel experience. Its walkable access to Pinecraft's Amish eateries and markets, private entry, and kitchenette appeal to independent travelers who value neighborhood character and self-catering flexibility. The compact one-bedroom layout with a futon also works for a couple traveling with one additional companion.
Travel tips
Having a car is helpful for reaching Sarasota's beaches and downtown, though the two nearby bus stops (within about 200 meters) offer a car-free option for shorter trips. Sarasota Bradenton International Airport, roughly 9.8 km away, is the most convenient airport, while Tampa, St. Pete-Clearwater, and Punta Gorda airports are all over an hour's drive. Tall guests should be mindful of the cottage's slanted roofline, and plan to use the on-site shared laundry and yard grill during your stay.
What guests say
Guests consistently praise Casa Lemon's cleanliness, comfort, and quiet, safe atmosphere, along with its convenient walking distance to Pinecraft's Amish restaurants and coffee shops. Several reviewers highlighted a comfortable bed and a responsive, friendly owner or staff. The on-site yard with a fire pit, grill, and yard games, plus supplied beach gear, were also called out as thoughtful touches. One reviewer noted the cottage's slanted roofline could be a minor issue for very tall guests, but overall feedback was strongly positive with no significant recurring complaints.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure