Comfort Inn Staten Island
310 Wild Ave, Staten Island, NY 10314, Staten Island, United States
4-star hotel
Guest rating: 3.3 / 5
Overview
Comfort Inn Staten Island is a casual, 4-star-rated hotel located off NY-440 on Wild Avenue in Staten Island, catering to travelers who want straightforward, no-frills lodging with easy road access. The property is decorated in warm, neutral tones and has a public rating of 3.3 from 589 reviews, reflecting a budget-to-midrange, functional stay rather than a luxury experience.
Rooms
Rooms are described as unfussy, with flat-screen TVs, cable TV, coffeemakers, free Wi-Fi and en suite bathrooms. Guests note that rooms run on the smaller side, sometimes lacking closet space, hangers, a dresser, a microwave or a fridge, so travelers with a lot of luggage or longer stays may want to pack accordingly.
Amenities & Recreation
The hotel offers complimentary breakfast, free parking, free Wi-Fi throughout, and an on-site exercise room for guests wanting to keep up a fitness routine. Meeting space and a business center are also available on site.
Dining
Free breakfast is included with a stay, providing a convenient start to the day without needing to leave the property. Some guests have reported billing discrepancies around breakfast pricing for groups, so it is worth confirming costs and any group arrangements directly with the front desk at check-in.
Location
Situated off NY-440, the hotel is about 4 miles from Historic Richmond Town, 3 miles from Willowbrook Park, and roughly 12 miles from the Hudson River Waterfront Walkway. It's also within driving distance of Staten Island Zoo (about 7.7 km), Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden and the New York Chinese Scholar's Garden (about 9.6-9.7 km), and the Verrazzano-Narrows Bridge (about 12.5 km), with Manhattan and Brooklyn attractions such as the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, Governors Island, The Battery, Coney Island and the New York Aquarium all located roughly 17-19 km away and best reached by car or ferry connection.
Best for
This hotel suits road-tripping travelers and budget-conscious visitors who want free parking, free Wi-Fi and complimentary breakfast in a no-frills setting off NY-440. It's also a reasonable base for those exploring Staten Island's own attractions -- Historic Richmond Town, Staten Island Zoo, and Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden -- rather than travelers prioritizing immediate proximity to Manhattan landmarks.
Travel tips
Since the Statue of Liberty, Ellis Island, and other Manhattan/Brooklyn sights are all roughly 17-19 km away, plan on driving or combining transit with a ferry connection to reach them. Historic Richmond Town, Staten Island Zoo, and Snug Harbor Cultural Center & Botanical Garden are much closer and make for easier half-day outings. Confirm breakfast pricing and any incidental/security deposit charges at check-in, as some guests have reported unexpected fees after checkout.
What guests say
Recurring positive themes in guest feedback include friendly staff, cleanliness, a comfortable bed, free parking, and the on-site exercise room. The most common complaint is that rooms are too small, often lacking sufficient closet space, hangers, a dresser, a microwave or a fridge, especially for multi-night stays. Some guests also reported disputes over post-checkout charges for alleged room damage and inconsistencies between quoted and charged breakfast prices for groups, which left a negative impression of value and billing transparency despite otherwise adequate basic amenities.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure