Islander Resort
4-star hotel
Guest rating: 4.5 / 5
Overview
Islander Resort is a relaxed, 4-star beachfront resort in Islamorada in the Florida Keys. It sits just off Highway 1 and is positioned for easy access to local museums, parks, and water-focused attractions. The property holds a strong public rating of 4.5/5 based on 1,646 reviews.
Suites & Townhouses
Accommodations are oriented toward longer, self-sufficient stays: unfussy suites include screened porches, BBQ facilities, and sitting areas with sofas, plus microwaves, refrigerators, and tea and coffeemakers. Upgraded quarters add Atlantic Ocean views. Colorful 2-story townhouses add bay views along with kitchens, balconies, and living rooms.
Dining & On-site Facilities
On-site dining includes a beachfront cafe and a casual restaurant. Parking is free, and the resort also offers boat slips. Conference facilities are available for meetings and group gatherings.
Recreation
The resort has an outdoor pool and direct beachfront positioning. Guest feedback also references on-site yoga offerings. Amenities beyond those documented are not listed in the provided data.
What’s Nearby
The Keys History & Discovery Center is a short walk away (about 139 m), with Upper Matecumbe Key nearby as well (about 375 m). Other close points of interest include Islamorada Brewery & Distillery (about 506 m), MoradaWay Arts & Cultural District (about 901 m), and the History of Diving Museum (about 1,551 m). For additional outings, Theater of the Sea is about 3,774 m away, with Windley Key Fossil Reef Geological State Park (about 5,438 m) and Indian Key Historic State Park (about 6,616 m) also within easy driving distance.
Best for
This resort is best suited to couples, families, and extended-stay travelers who value suite and townhouse-style layouts with kitchens or kitchenettes, plus extras like screened porches and BBQ facilities. It also fits travelers who want to be near Islamorada’s museums and cultural stops, including the Keys History & Discovery Center (walkable) and the History of Diving Museum (about a mile away). Boaters and small groups may also appreciate the available boat slips and conference facilities.
Travel tips
Because the resort is just off Highway 1, having a car can make it much easier to reach attractions like Theater of the Sea, Robbie’s of Islamorada, and nearby state parks. If you’re planning ocean activities, note that some guests have mentioned seaweed and odor affecting the shoreline at times; consider flexible plans such as pool time or visiting museums and the MoradaWay Arts & Cultural District. For local tastings, Islamorada Brewery & Distillery is close by (about 506 m).
What guests say
Guests frequently praise the resort’s location and describe the rooms as very nice, with overall service and staff often highlighted positively. Some reviews mention the convenience of being able to drive up to rooms and appreciate activities like yoga. Recurring drawbacks include occasional maintenance issues in-room and small bathrooms. Beachfront conditions can be a concern at times, with some guests reporting heavy seaweed and odor affecting shoreline enjoyment, and pool-area shade (umbrellas) and included items tied to resort fees not always meeting expectations.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure