New Rome Motel

5246 W Broad St, Columbus, OH 43228, Columbus, United States

2-star hotel

Guest rating: 3.1 / 5

New Rome Motel is a budget, 2-star roadside property located at 5246 W Broad St on the west side of Columbus, Ohio. It offers a no-frills, economy motel experience, with no amenities formally documented for the property. Guest accounts suggest compact, older-style rooms furnished in a dated, roadside-motel manner rather than modern hotel finishes. There is no on-site dining noted, so guests should plan to rely on nearby restaurants and fast-food options along W Broad St. The motel sits about 2.8 km from Hollywood Casino Columbus, making it a convenient low-cost base for casino visitors, while downtown Columbus attractions such as the Ohio Statehouse, COSI, and the Columbus Museum of Art are roughly 11-16 km away and require a car to reach. Its public rating of 3.1 from 218 reviews reflects a split experience between guests satisfied with the price-to-value ratio and others reporting maintenance and service concerns.

Best for

This motel best suits budget-conscious travelers and road-trippers looking for a low-cost overnight stay near Hollywood Casino Columbus, which is just under 3 km away. It may also work for guests who need a basic, no-frills place to sleep while passing through the west Columbus area rather than those seeking amenity-rich accommodations.

Travel tips

A personal vehicle is recommended, since most named points of interest -- including COSI, the Ohio Statehouse, and Franklin Park Conservatory -- sit 11-16 km away in downtown Columbus and are not within easy walking distance. Hollywood Casino Columbus is the closest notable destination at under 3 km, making it a practical anchor point for planning an evening out. Given mixed reviews on room condition, travelers may want to inspect the room upon check-in before settling in.

What guests say

Guest feedback is notably mixed. Some reviewers highlight satisfactory rooms, friendly staff, and affordable pricing as reasons for a positive stay. However, a recurring and more frequent theme involves dissatisfaction with the physical condition of the property, including outdated and worn furniture, small and cramped rooms, and a general sense that the motel needs renovation. Cleanliness concerns are also mentioned, with at least one guest describing conditions poor enough to prefer sleeping elsewhere. Additionally, some reviews cite negative interactions with front-desk staff during evening shifts, describing unprofessional or disrespectful conduct.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure