Saint Nicholas Inn B&B

885 St Nicholas Ave, New York, NY 10032, New York, United States

2-star hotel

Guest rating: 3.7 / 5

The Saint Nicholas Inn B&B occupies a 19th-century redbrick townhouse in Manhattan's Sugar Hill historic district, blending original period accents and detailed plasterwork with the informality of a small bed-and-breakfast. The property holds just four guest rooms, each outfitted with Wi-Fi, satellite TV, and a coffeemaker, and most rooms share bathroom facilities; one suite steps up with a kitchenette, a sitting area, and its own en suite bathroom. A continental breakfast is served each morning in a homey breakfast room, giving the inn a lived-in, residential feel rather than a standard hotel atmosphere. It sits less than a minute's walk from the nearest subway station, putting Manhattan's wider sightseeing circuit -- including Central Park, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, the Guggenheim, and the American Museum of Natural History, all roughly 5-6 kilometers away -- within a short ride. Times Square, Rockefeller Center, Grand Central Terminal, and the Empire State Building are also reachable, generally 7-10 kilometers off, while Yankee Stadium is about a mile from the front door. As a 2-star property with a 3.7 rating from 90 reviews, it suits travelers prioritizing character and value over full-service amenities. Minimum-stay requirements may apply depending on dates.

Best for

This inn is best suited to budget-conscious travelers, solo visitors, and couples who value historic character and a personal, homestay-style atmosphere over hotel amenities. Its subway proximity makes it a practical base for guests planning to spend most of their time sightseeing across Manhattan, from Central Park's museums to Midtown landmarks. Baseball fans will also appreciate the roughly one-mile distance to Yankee Stadium.

Travel tips

Take advantage of the subway stop just steps from the property to reach Central Park, the Metropolitan Museum of Art, and other Midtown attractions, most of which are a 5- to 10-kilometer transit ride away rather than walkable. Since several rooms share bathrooms, guests preferring en suite facilities should ask about the suite when booking. Confirm any minimum-stay requirements in advance, as they may apply depending on your travel dates.

What guests say

Guests frequently praise the attentiveness and warmth of the staff, describing service that felt caring and personal. The continental breakfast is another recurring highlight, with reviewers noting a good variety of options and satisfying quality. Some guests mention that certain rooms lack a private bathroom, though the shared facilities are consistently described as clean and well-kept, suggesting this is a minor trade-off rather than a significant complaint.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure