Sunset Key Cottages

245 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, Key West, United States

4-star hotel

Guest rating: 4.6 / 5

Overview

Sunset Key Cottages is a 4-star oceanfront resort set on a private 27-acre island just off Key West. The property is reached via a short boat ride (about 5–7 minutes) from Key West, offering a quieter, more secluded setting while staying close to Old Town attractions. It is located at 245 Front St, Key West, FL 33040, and is about 4 miles from Key West International Airport.

Cottages (Accommodations)

Accommodations are bright 1- to 4-bedroom cottages with living and dining areas designed for longer stays as well as quick getaways. Standard features include free Wi‑Fi, flat-screen TVs, coffeemakers, and pillow-top mattresses; many cottages also include full kitchens. Upgraded units add ocean-view balconies or patios, and some include whirlpool tubs.

Dining

On-site dining includes an informal restaurant/bar plus a poolside bar. Guests frequently highlight the overall food quality and atmosphere, and cottage guests may find it easier to secure reservations compared with the general public demand. In-room dining experiences are also part of the stay experience, including breakfasts delivered to cottages and catered meals arranged for special occasions.

Amenities & Recreation

Resort amenities include a beach, a pool, two whirlpools, a gym, and a spa. Boat transfers between the island and Key West are complimentary, with frequent departures noted by guests. The private-island setting is geared toward relaxed, resort-style days with easy access back to town when desired.

Nearby Highlights (Key West)

Once in Key West, notable nearby sights include Mallory Square (about 755 m) and the Sunset Celebration at Mallory Square (about 748 m), plus the Key West Aquarium (about 830 m) and the Key West Shipwreck Museum (about 865 m). Other popular stops include the Truman Little White House (about 1,064 m), Sloppy Joe’s Bar (about 1,038 m), the Mel Fisher Maritime Museum (about 964 m), and the Hemingway Home and Museum (about 1,911 m). Beach and nature options in the wider area include Fort Zachary Taylor Historic State Park Beach (about 1,878 m) and the Key West Butterfly and Nature Conservatory (about 2,467 m).

Best for

This resort best suits travelers who want a private-island retreat while staying close to Old Town Key West, thanks to complimentary boat transfers and the short ride to town. It’s especially well matched to couples or groups planning longer stays, as cottages range from 1 to 4 bedrooms and include living/dining areas and (in many cases) full kitchens. Guests who prioritize service, food, and an easy, resort-style routine (beach, pool, spa, and in-cottage breakfasts) tend to find it a strong fit.

Travel tips

Plan your Key West sightseeing around the complimentary boat transfers, since the resort is on a private island and access to town depends on the boat schedule. Mallory Square and the Sunset Celebration are among the closest major attractions once you’re in town, along with the Key West Aquarium and Shipwreck Museum. If dining on-site is a priority, consider arranging reservations early, as the restaurant is known to be in high demand.

What guests say

Guest feedback frequently emphasizes the unique private-island setting paired with very convenient access to Key West via a short boat ride. Service stands out as a consistent strength, with staff attention and overall hospitality repeatedly highlighted. Reviews also point to strong dining experiences and enjoyable ambience, including the appeal of breakfast delivered to cottages and the ability to dine in-cottage for special occasions. Cottage comfort and practicality (including kitchens for longer stays) are commonly cited as reasons guests return. No recurring negative themes are evident in the provided excerpts.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure