The Timbrook Guesthouse: A Unique Luxury Inn
5811 Olentangy River Rd, Columbus, OH 43235, New California, United States
Guest rating: 4.9 / 5
Overview
The Timbrook Guesthouse is a boutique bed-and-breakfast set inside a restored 1875 colonial farmhouse in Columbus, Ohio. Run by hosts Jill and Peter, the property blends historic architecture with a curated, upscale guest experience. It has earned a near-perfect 4.9 rating from 205 reviews, with guests repeatedly describing it as a one-of-a-kind escape rather than a typical hotel stay.
Grounds & Amenities
The estate sits on gorgeous, immaculately maintained grounds that guests describe as a country-town blend, giving the property a peaceful, unhurried atmosphere. An outdoor pool is a highlight of the on-site amenities, offering a place to relax during warmer months. The overall setting and attention to detail are frequently singled out as distinctive compared to standard accommodations.
Dining
A seasonal breakfast is included and consistently mentioned by guests as one of the standout parts of their stay, with hosts preparing home-cooked, beautifully presented meals each morning. The breakfast experience is described as a genuine highlight rather than a routine continental spread, contributing significantly to the inn's reputation.
Location
The guesthouse is located at 5811 Olentangy River Rd in Columbus, Ohio, within the New California area. Guests note that despite its quiet, secluded feel, it remains conveniently close to Columbus-area attractions and restaurants, striking a balance between rural charm and city access.
Best for
This property is best suited to couples and small groups seeking a romantic, celebratory getaway, such as birthdays or anniversaries, given its intimate scale, personalized hosting, and standout breakfast service. It also appeals to travelers who value historic character and beautifully kept grounds over standard hotel amenities, thanks to its 1875 farmhouse setting and outdoor pool.
Travel tips
Because this is a small, host-run guesthouse rather than a large hotel, guests should coordinate arrival times and breakfast preferences directly with Jill and Peter. The outdoor pool and seasonal breakfast are best enjoyed by planning a stay outside of peak winter months. Its Columbus location keeps it within reach of area restaurants and attractions while still offering a quiet, rural-feeling retreat.
What guests say
Guests consistently praise the property's historic charm, describing the 1875 farmhouse setting and grounds as gorgeous and unique compared to typical accommodations. The seasonal, home-cooked breakfast is repeatedly highlighted as an exceptional part of the stay, alongside attentive, personalized hosting from Jill and Peter. Reviewers also mention the outdoor pool, comfortable beds, and immaculate upkeep of the property as standout features. No recurring negative themes appear in the excerpts provided.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure