Three Judges Motor Lodge

Three Judges Motor Lodge

1560 Whalley Ave, New Haven, CT 06515, New Haven, United States

Guest rating: 2.7 / 5

Overview

Three Judges Motor Lodge is a motor lodge in New Haven, Connecticut, located at 1560 Whalley Ave. Its star class is not documented, and its public rating is 2.7 based on 133 reviews. It’s positioned for practical, drive-up style stays on the city’s west side.

Location

The property sits on Whalley Avenue, with guests noting convenient proximity to everyday stops like gas stations and fast-food options. Yale University is roughly 5.1 km away, with nearby cultural stops including the Yale University Art Gallery (about 5.0 km) and the Yale Center for British Art (about 5.1 km). Additional nearby attractions include New Haven Green (about 5.4 km) and East Rock Park (about 6.1 km).

Nearby attractions

For museums and local history, guests can reach the New Haven Museum (about 5.3 km), the Yale Peabody Museum (about 5.2 km), and the Eli Whitney Museum & Workshop (about 5.5 km). For family-friendly outings farther afield, options include the It Adventure Ropes Course (about 6.9 km), the PEZ Visitor Center (about 8.3 km), and the Shore Line Trolley Museum (about 11.8 km). Outdoor destinations within a longer drive include Lighthouse Point Park (about 11.6 km) and Silver Sands State Park (about 17.0 km).

Best for

This motor lodge is best suited to budget-minded travelers who prioritize a practical New Haven base near everyday conveniences like gas stations and fast-food chains. It can also work for visitors planning to spend most of their time off-site exploring Yale University and the cluster of museums and galleries about 5 km away. Travelers who are sensitive to cleanliness should weigh recent guest feedback carefully before booking.

Travel tips

If your plans center on Yale and downtown New Haven sights, expect to travel roughly 5–6 km from the lodge to major landmarks like Yale University, the Yale art museums, and New Haven Green. East Rock Park is also within a short drive (about 6.1 km), making it an easy add-on for a quick outdoor break. For longer excursions, Lighthouse Point Park (about 11.6 km) and Silver Sands State Park (about 17.0 km) are better planned as dedicated outings.

What guests say

Guest feedback highlights a convenient, practical location with easy access to everyday stops such as gas stations and fast-food options. Reviews are mixed on cleanliness: some guests report clean rooms, while others describe serious cleanliness and pest concerns, including bathroom dirt and roaches. Staff interactions are mentioned positively by some reviewers. Overall sentiment suggests a functional location but inconsistent condition and upkeep.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure