Toiyabe Motel

107045 US-395, Coleville, CA 96107, Coleville, United States

2-star hotel

Guest rating: 4.5 / 5

Toiyabe Motel is a no-frills, two-star roadside motel set directly on US-395 in the small Sierra-adjacent community of Coleville, California. Guest rooms are wood-paneled with exterior entrances, offering free Wi-Fi, flat-screen TVs, microwaves, minifridges, and tea/coffeemakers, along with private bathrooms (some with tubs). Outdoors, the property maintains a relaxed garden area with BBQ grills and a courtyard set up for food prep, a detail appreciated by hunters and anglers passing through. Free parking is available on-site, and pets are welcome with prior arrangement. The motel sits about a mile from the athletic fields at Mountain Gate Park and roughly 28 miles from the hiking and fishing grounds of Stanislaus National Forest, with Topaz Lake, Lobdell Lake, Kirman Lake, and Mount Patterson all within a 12-19 km radius for outdoor day trips. Walker Burger and Mountain View Barbeque are both within a few hundred meters for casual dining, and a bus stop sits about a kilometer away. This is a straightforward, budget-friendly base for travelers moving along Route 395 rather than a destination resort.

Best for

This motel best suits outdoor-focused travelers -- hunters, anglers, and hikers -- who value the on-site grilling/food-prep courtyard and proximity to Topaz Lake, Lobdell Lake, Kirman Lake, and Stanislaus National Forest. It also works well for road-trippers on US-395 who need a simple, affordable overnight stop with free parking, free Wi-Fi, and in-room basics like a microwave and minifridge. Pet owners traveling through rural eastern California will also appreciate that pets are accepted with prior arrangement.

Travel tips

Because the motel is located directly on US-395, a car is essential for reaching nearby lakes and forest areas, most of which are 12-19 km away. Dining options right in town are limited but convenient, with Walker Burger and Mountain View Barbeque both within a short walk; farther-flung restaurants like Virginia Creek Settlement or The Barn require a 30+ km drive. Reno-Tahoe International Airport is over 110 km away, so plan for roughly a 1.5-hour drive if flying in or out.

What guests say

Many reviewers describe the rooms as cozy and appreciate friendly, helpful service, along with the convenience of the outdoor courtyard for food prep and grilling, which is especially popular with hunters and anglers. Guests also highlight the quiet, small-town setting with nearby food and drink options like a bar, general store, and milkshake spot. However, a recurring negative theme involves a recent decline in property upkeep, reportedly following a change in ownership, with complaints about an unkempt picnic/BBQ area, uncleaned rooms, and deteriorating bathroom conditions. A few guests also noted communication difficulties with non-English-speaking staff and frustration over an undisclosed cleaning fee charged at checkout.

Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure