The City Cabin - Unique and Historic
Guest rating: 4.3 / 5
The City Cabin - Unique and Historic is a pet-friendly, smoke-free three-bedroom log-cabin stay in Ohio, set in Old North Columbus just north of The Ohio State University area. Dating to 1805 and described as the oldest structure in Franklin County, the cabin has been moved and modified over two centuries and is styled to feel rustic while offering modern basics such as air conditioning, heating, free Wi-Fi, cable TV, and in-unit laundry (washer). The layout includes a main-floor living room with a fireplace and TV, a large bedroom with a double bed and a half bath, plus two upstairs bedrooms (one double, one with two twin beds) and a full bathroom; there’s also an on-site “hidden room” feature and outdoor seating in a partially fenced yard. A kitchen setup is provided with a microwave, and the home includes practical extras like an ironing board and free parking (one off-alley space, plus nearby street parking). Dining is walkable, with options like bb.q Chicken Columbus (about 223 m) and Cazuelas Mexican Cantina (about 279 m), plus additional restaurants along High Street. Public transit access is close, with multiple bus stops nearby including N High St & E Northwood Ave (about 105 m away).
Best for
Best suited to travelers who want a distinctive, historic home base near the OSU/High Street corridor and who value character over a standardized hotel experience. It can work well for small groups or friends traveling together thanks to the three-bedroom layout, living-room gathering space with fireplace, and on-site laundry, plus free parking and Wi-Fi.
Travel tips
If you plan to use public transit, the closest bus stop is N High St & E Northwood Ave (about 105 m), with several other High Street stops within a short walk. Rideshares are a common way to get around from this central area, and the host notes typical drive times of under 10 minutes to downtown and under 20 minutes to many other parts of Columbus. Expect a check-in requirement: guests must provide a valid ID and sign a rental agreement to receive arrival instructions, and parties/unauthorized gatherings are prohibited; pet fees also apply based on length of stay.
What guests say
Guest feedback highlights the location as a key advantage, particularly for proximity to the Ohio State University area. Negative themes focus on discrepancies between advertised and available amenities, especially around cooking facilities, and on maintenance/condition issues such as unstable furniture and limited electrical outlets. Safety-related concerns are also mentioned, including stair features and general suitability for children. Overall sentiment in the provided excerpts skews strongly negative due to perceived shortcomings in amenities and upkeep despite the appealing location.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure