The Goldfinch Cottage Mid-Century 3-bd retreat in lakeside Miller Beach WiFi, AC
Guest rating: 5.0 / 5
Overview
The Goldfinch Cottage is a restored mid-century, three-bedroom lake cottage set in the artistic lakeside neighborhood of Miller Beach in New Chicago. Shaded by century-old black savannah oak trees, the property offers a quiet, residential alternative to a standard hotel stay, putting guests close to the Indiana Dunes National Park and Lake Michigan shoreline.
Rooms & Sleeping Space
Each of the three bedrooms has a queen bed with upgraded bedding, and a cozy sofa bed in the living area adds sleeping space for extra guests. The living room features a fireplace, a 76-inch smart TV, and board games such as Scrabble and croquet for evenings in.
Amenities
The cottage is equipped with Nest-controlled air conditioning and heating, free Wi-Fi, cable TV, an in-unit washer, an oven and stove, an ironing board, and free parking. It is smoke-free and pet-friendly, and a large outdoor patio with its own fireplace extends the living space outside under the oak canopy.
Location & Surroundings
Miller Beach's dining scene is within easy reach, including nearby bars and grills like Beach Box and Estella's Cantina and restaurants such as Ember and Oak Smokehouse, Tiny's Restaurant & Bar, and J J Fish & Chicken, all under 3km away. A local bus stop (Locust & Montgomery) is about 312 meters away and the Miller train station is roughly 2.8km away, with Chicago Midway and O'Hare airports both accessible by car for onward travel.
Best for
This cottage suits families or small groups traveling together who want separate bedrooms, a full kitchen setup, and laundry facilities rather than a standard hotel room. It's also a good fit for beach and nature lovers, given its walkable access to Miller Beach and proximity to the Indiana Dunes National Park, plus pet owners thanks to its pet-friendly policy.
Travel tips
The beach itself is reachable on foot via a nearby access point just a couple of streets over, so a car isn't strictly necessary for a beach day. For dining out, several bars, grills, and restaurants sit within a 1-3km radius, making an evening walk or short drive an easy option. Those flying in should note Chicago Midway is closer than O'Hare, though both require a drive of over 45km.
What guests say
Guests consistently highlight the quality of the host, describing attentive and helpful hospitality throughout their stay. Reviewers also mention discovering a convenient nearby beach access point just a couple of streets from the cottage, adding to the appeal of the location. Overall sentiment is uniformly positive, with guests expressing interest in returning, and no recurring complaints appear in the available feedback.
Check availability · Booking links may earn us a commission at no extra cost to you. Affiliate disclosure